This quick feature on Blue Jays catcher Russell Martin gave us some insight into how he calls games. J.A. Happ had struggled in an outing against the Angels and had to face them again less than a month later. Happ was much better the second time around, so many assumed adjustments were made. Martin said he couldn’t remember much about that first Happ outing against the Angels and continued:
“That’s pretty much how baseball is,” Martin shrugged, when asked about his head-scratching Happ-nesia.
“It’s really not that complicated. You go out there and he’s going to pitch to his strengths and do what he’s comfortable with and what works for him, and that’s it. You know a well-located pitch is going to be tough for anybody to hit, whether you’re an MVP or a September call-up.”
“Just because you have a bad start against somebody the last time has no bearing on the result of what the next game’s going to be,” Martin said. “Different ballpark, different conditions. One day is one day.
This is very much a process-over-results approach to calling games as a catcher. Martin continued in explaining his strategy:
“Obviously there are times where you look at a sample and then you say, ‘Okay this guy is 15-for-20 off this guy with five home runs, you might want to be careful.’ But you can’t have a one-game impact. If he gets hit by one team you can’t be like, ‘We’re going to do things completely different here.’ (Happ’s) strength is his fastball and you kind of go off that.”
Martin argued that, yes, it’s important to know a hitter’s weaknesses but it’s more important to know his pitcher’s strengths. There is so much video available now, with opposing hitters studying the next starter, looking for tendencies in counts and situations, that a starter like Marco Estrada might actually benefit from having Dioner Navarro and Martin catching him at different times.
Martin also discussed how no two catchers are the same and what made former Blue Jay starter Mark Buehrle successful.